By thredUP's own yardstick it is not overpriced, but most of it is no longer cheap. On November 18, 2026, we read 25 brands on thredUP's US store and compared each thredUP-priced item's list price with the estimated original retail thredUP puts next to it. The median item was 60% off thredUP's own estimated retail, and the median of the 25 brand medians was 63%. Few items are the "basics for $5-20" the thread misses: 7.6% of items from the 13 brands shoppers name were listed under $20. Across all 25 brands it was 18.2%, but that figure rests mostly on four budget brands. All of it came from POST /api/v1/thredup/brand on Scavio's thredUP API.
The question comes from r/ThredUp. A shopper posted "I'd shop more if prices weren't absurd." on December 11, 2025; when we read it on November 18, 2026, it had 178 upvotes and 31 comments. The poster wrote that they would not pay "$40 for a used Banana Republic top", and remembered buying basics "for $5-20".
The replies are the commenters' own experiences, not data:
- The top comment (61 points) described waiting for wishlist prices to drop and comparing a used Athleta sweater thredUP "wanted $33 for on sale".
- Another (36 points) said "I only shop sales".
- A third (15 points) asked how to tell when thredUP has a sale, because "they portray every day as a sale day".
- One (11 points) said they "look on Poshmark or EBay" instead.
thredUP's filings say buyers shop "at up to 90% off estimated retail price", and its help page says the struck-through price is "the estimated original retail price of a comparable item sold new". So two parts of the complaint are checkable:
- How far below that estimate are items listed?
- How many are listed at basics prices?
We checked both.
How we compared
We fixed the brands before reading any prices:
- The 13 brands shoppers name: every brand named in this thread or its comments, or in three AI answers to "thredUP vs Poshmark". Those are Banana Republic, Athleta, J.Crew, Madewell, Ann Taylor, Ann Taylor LOFT, Free People, Lululemon Athletica, Ralph Lauren, Old Navy, Zara, Coach and Tory Burch.
- 12 more: the brands that came up most often on page 1 of thredUP's women's new arrivals, clearance and Under $10 collections. Those are One Step Up, MICHAEL Michael Kors, Kate Spade New York, Shein, Susan Lawrence, Pact, Anthropologie, Badgley Mischka, Disturbia, Gap, Lands' End and Nike.
For each brand we read page 1 of brand in the women's department (handbags for Coach), 119 items in thredUP's own order. We read it twice: once filtered to items thredUP prices (seller_type: ["thredup"]), once to Direct Listings. That was 50 calls between 18:05 and 18:23 UTC, plus 10 calls for women's tops. The caveats, which matter here:
- List prices, before any code. 2,810 of the 2,869 thredUP-priced items also showed a 50% first-order code. A code is a discount on top, so a returning shopper sees the list price, and every figure here is that price.
- One day, logged out, first page. These are the first 119 items thredUP showed for each brand on November 18, as a visitor with no account sees them. They are not every listing, and not a Black Friday price.
- The estimated retail is an estimate. thredUP's merchants set it on thredUP-priced items, and its help page calls pricing "not an exact science". On Direct Listings the seller enters it.
- Ralph Lauren and Disturbia count in the totals but are not shown per brand. The exact name "Ralph Lauren" covers only part of the brand's items on thredUP, and Disturbia had 25 items in all.
What the prices show
- Basics prices are rare in the brands people name. 117 of the 1,547 thredUP-priced items from the 13 named brands (7.6%) were listed under $20. Their median list price was $54.99, and 1,015 of them (66%) were $40 or more. Across all 25 brands, 523 of 2,869 items (18.2%) were under $20. 392 of those 523 came from four budget brands: Susan Lawrence (119 of 119), One Step Up (117 of 119), Shein (95 of 119) and Old Navy (61 of 119).
- Against thredUP's own estimate, the discounts are real. The median thredUP-priced item was 60% off its estimated retail, and the median brand 63%. The middle half of items ran 44% to 70% off. Only 19 of 2,863 items (0.7%) reached the "up to 90% off" thredUP advertises, and 28.2% were at 70% or more.
- The $40 Banana Republic top is close to typical. Page 1 of Banana Republic women's tops held 119 items, all thredUP-priced:
- median list price $34.99, middle half $26.99 to $48.99;
- 49 (41%) at $40 or more, and 11 (9%) under $20;
- a median 72% off thredUP's estimated retail;
- the 22 tops that listed polyester had a median of $32.49, and 7 of them were $40 or more.
- Athleta, for the top commenter's sweater: Athleta's women's tops had a median of $33.99. Its brand page had a median of $43.99, at 58% off.
- Poshmark was lower for these tops on this day. Page 1 of women's tops for 10 brands on Poshmark US (48 items each) had a lower median price than thredUP's for all 10. Banana Republic tops were $18 there against $34.99 on thredUP, and the median brand's thredUP price was about 1.6 times its Poshmark price. Both are list prices without shipping, and Poshmark sellers take offers. It is 10 brands' tops on one day, not a rule.
- Direct Listings are a different number. Direct Listing items had a median price of $43.99, against $48.99 for thredUP-priced items, and none was under $20. The lowest was $21.99, and thredUP sets a $20 minimum. 385 of 2,597 Direct Listings (14.8%) showed a price above the retail their seller entered; thredUP says its buyer fee is included in the Direct Listing price. A second r/ThredUp thread, "Anyone else think direct listing prices are crazy?" (February 15, 2026), is about exactly that split. Commenters there filter Direct Listings out with the "sold by" option.
- Sales were thin on this day. Clearance was 76 of 2,869 thredUP-priced items (2.6%). We did not capture a Black Friday sale.
What this cannot tell you
- Whether a price is fair for a given item. We measured list prices against thredUP's own estimate, not against what the same item costs new today.
- What you pay at checkout. The figures are before codes, shipping and any account-specific offer. Some r/ThredUp users report seeing different prices on different accounts; we read as a logged-out visitor and cannot test that.
- How prices moved over time. This is one day. thredUP shows no price history, so the "prices used to be $5-20" memory is the poster's, not something we can check.
- Every listing. These are the first page per brand in thredUP's order, 25 brands, women's department.
Run the comparison yourself
curl -s https://api.scavio.dev/api/v1/thredup/brand \
-H "Authorization: Bearer $SCAVIO_API_KEY" \
-H "Content-Type: application/json" \
-d '{"brand": "Banana Republic", "department": "women", "category": "tops", "seller_type": ["thredup"]}'How to read the answer:
- Each of the 119 items carries
price,estimated_retail,percent_off,condition,materialsandseller_type. - Count the items with
priceunder 20, and take the median ofpercent_off. - Send
"seller_type": ["direct_listing"]for the Direct Listing side.
How to get thredUP prices walks through every call with captured responses. The best thredUP secondhand price APIs has the per-brand percent-off chart. Try the thredUP API free: 50 credits read 50 brand pages.
This is price research, not buying or selling advice.
Frequently asked questions
Why is thredUP so expensive?
We cannot measure why, only how far. On November 18, 2026, the median thredUP-priced item across 25 brands was 60% off thredUP's estimated retail, but only 7.6% of items from the 13 brands shoppers name were listed under $20, and their median list price was $54.99.
Is the estimated retail on thredUP accurate?
It is an estimate. thredUP's help says the struck-through price is the estimated original retail of a comparable item sold new, set by a team that monitors market prices, and that pricing is not an exact science; on Direct Listings the seller enters it. Compare it with the price new yourself.
Are Direct Listings on thredUP more expensive?
Not consistently in our read. Direct Listing items had a median price of $43.99 against $48.99 for thredUP-priced items across 25 brands, and were lower in 13 of 23 brands, but none was under $20 because Direct Listings have a $20 minimum, and their retail figure is entered by the seller.
Is thredUP cheaper than Poshmark?
Not for the women's tops we compared on November 18, 2026: for 10 brands, thredUP's median list price was higher than Poshmark US for all 10, Banana Republic tops $34.99 against $18. That leaves out shipping, codes and offers, and covers one category on one day.
How can I check thredUP prices with code?
Scavio's thredUP API returns a brand's items with POST /api/v1/thredup/brand, 119 a page with price, estimated_retail, percent_off, condition and seller_type, for 1 credit a page. Filter seller_type to thredup or direct_listing, count items under $20 and take the median percent_off.